
The other day, I posted a blog on a news story, “Teen stabs boyfriend after he refuses sex.” A 19-year-old teen girl reportedly woke up her 35-year-old boyfriend to “make love” in their bedroom, but her boyfriend refused and went to sleep on the living room couch. Then after further disagreement, the teen girl allegedly stabbed her boyfriend on the lip with a long knife-like metal object.
I mentioned that this unusual news story raised a number of questions in my mind, and I promised to get back to this story and give my reaction to these questions, so here goes:
Is it wise for a teen girl to pursue an unmarried sexual relationship with a man in his mid-30’s? “No,” for a number of reasons. Here’s some of them, and if you think of more reasons, please write a comment to this blog. [1] Having regular unmarried sex increases the chances that the teen girl will become pregnant, and even if she or he uses contraceptives, they are not 100% effective. If the teen girl got pregnant, she and her baby would not have the same level of legal protections and legal commitment for financial support from the father that come with marriage. [2] Research found that children suffer more emotional, behavioral, and academic problems if they grow up with parents who cohabitate compared to children who grow with married parents. (Susan L. Brown, Family structure and child well-being: The significance of parental cohabitation, Journal of Marriage and Family, 2004, volume 66, pages 351-364.) So having unmarried sex involves the possibility of creating a child, and so the decision should include that possible child’s well-being.
Why didn’t the teen girl just leave him alone when he turned down her sexual advance? In any human relationship, we should honor and respect the wishes of the other person, and when it comes to something as significant as a sexual relationship, it is morally wrong to force anyone to have sex who says “No.” If the teen girl genuinely loved the older man, she would not even want to force him to do something he did not want to do at the time. This news story is somewhat unusual in that it is more typical for a guy to try to pressure a teen girl to have sex when she really does not want to have sex. Many guys will use some version of the line, “If you truly loved me, you’d have sex with me.” But, in fact, if the guy truly loved the girl, he would not be pressuring her to do something she preferred not to do. In this news story, the tables are turned, and the teen girl reportedly pressured the guy to have sex when he did not want to have sex. So why didn’t she just leave him alone when he turned down her sexual advance? It looks like it is highly likely that she did not truly love and respect the man for who he is and for the decision he made. Which leads us to the next question….
Would a teen with true “love” for her boyfriend end up stabbing the person loved? Obviously, “NO.” Stabbing a person is not a loving act. Occasionally a person under tremendous stress who is very tired and upset might do something people describe as “out of character,” but if a person harms another person, they are actually revealing their true underlying character at some level. Which leads us again to the next question….
Did the teen girl really want to “make love” or just have sexual gratification? It looks like it is highly possible that this teen girl was motivated by her own selfish desire for immediate sexual gratification for herself. From what we can tell from the news story and the arrest records that I read, there was no evidence of true “love” in this teen girl’s actions on the day she was arrested for stabbing her boyfriend.
What psychological conditions would contribute to this episode? From the limited details we have, we can only make some guesses, and cannot be certain. But some people stab others who have any of these diagnoses, for example: a Psychotic Disorder, Delusional Disorder, Antisocial Personality Disorder, Narcissistic Personality Disorder, or Histrionic Personality Disorder, or Borderline Personality Disorder. But normally, teenagers have not fully developed one of the personality disorders, which are usually diagnosed after some adulthood years. We really cannot tell what diagnosis this teen girl might or might not have from the limited information in the news story. In fact, she might not have any psychological disorder, but just be an evil, selfish person who is showing her true underlying nature.
The moral of the story: [1] True love does not try to force anyone to have sex. [2] Sex is most meaningful when it involves true love between the partners—so Sex plus Love is vastly better than Sex minus Love. [3] Sex + Love + Marriage is vastly better than Sex + Love, for many reasons. One reason is that Sex + Love + Marriage provides a greater degree of protection and benefits to the father, to the mother, and to the child who could be conceived by the act of sexual intercourse.
What do you think? E-mail any comments or questions you might have about this story to: teensextoday@ProfessorGeorge.com or just write to me on my blog. If we post what you write, we will keep it anonymous. Count on me to be logical, ethical, and scientific in my answers.
–Professor George
George A. Rekers, Ph.D., FAACP
Distinguished Professor of Neuropsychiatry and Behavioral Science Emeritus
University of South Carolina School of Medicine
© Copyright, 2008, Professor George LLC
www.ProfessorGeorge.com
Recent Comments